How many times can you use a paint roller? Jerry has had some last 3 to 4 years by keeping them submerged in paint in a five-gallon bucket. While you can clean a roller using a Painters Tool and water, it takes effort and can damage the nap. If you're in a hurry, leave a lot of paint on the roller, put it in a sealed plastic bag, and reuse. Shop Hyde's full lineup of roller covers at https://hydetools.com/collections/rollers | Hyde Tools